PlayStation has been ahead of Xbox for generations when it comes to exclusive games, but Microsoft has been putting the pressure on Sony in recent years with its Game Pass service. In response, PlayStation introduced its new PlayStation Plus tier system earlier this week, offering players access to game trials, cloud gaming, and — finally — a catalog of games to play.

It’s that last bonus we’re here to walk you through today. The PlayStation Plus Game Catalog is a perk in both the PlayStation Plus Extra and Premium tiers, which will run players either $14.99 or $17.99 a month, respectively. The Game Catalog works similarly to Game Pass, with games rotating in and out of the service over time.

While the Game Catalog isn’t going to offer new, first-party Sony games the day they’re released, its library is already starting out in a great place. Sony is offering some of the best AAA games out there for players who subscribe to the higher tiers, taking advantage of the PlayStation 4 and 5’s excellent library of single-player games.

The PlayStation Plus Game Catalog can be overwhelming to scroll through, though. That’s where we can help. We’ve listed the 17 best games on the service — OK, technically it’s 19 — to help you figure out where to start your Game Catalog journey.

BATMAN: ARKHAM KNIGHT

Batman: Ark ham Knight is the conclusion to Rock steady’s Batman trilogy, and it goes for broke. Arkham Knight is most well known for its addition of the controversial Batmobile to the nearly every piece of the trilogy’s formula. There are still dungeons to delve into and crimes to solve on the rooftops — but the Batmobile helps players break into new areas, rescue civilians, battle remote-controlled tanks, solve puzzles, and traverse Gotham at high speeds.

But despite its notoriety, the Batmobile is not what makes Arkham Knight so good. The third entry explores the relationship between Batman and Joker in surprising ways, and their connection fuels some of the game’s biggest moments and set-pieces.

It’s a worthy finale to the Rocksteady trilogy and a great Batman game to dive into, even if you’ve never played any of the others.

BLOOD BORNE

Bloodborne is a PlayStation 4 classic. It takes From Software’s beloved but brutal game play and transports it to a Gothic Love antiaircraft setting. As the Hunter, you must haunt the streets of Harmony, taking on its hostile citizens and grotesque mysteries.

Much of what Blood borne does best can also be found in From’s other titles, but unlike Dark Souls and Elden Ring, Blood borne forces you into an aggressive play style. When you take damage, you can strike the enemy back to regain some health. What’s more, the shields and heavy armor found in similar titles are absent here, so it’s more about careful dodges than making a damage-resistant build.

Blood borne became an instant classic upon its release, and its still one of the best PlayStation exclusives because it marries near-flawless game play with immaculate vibes.

CELESTE

Celeste is a hyper-difficult platformer with a smorgasbord of worlds and mechanics to keep players on their toes. It’s a game that gets brutally difficult over time, and offers even more punishing options once players have mastered its moves. But it’s also an incredible story about mental health, acceptance, and one of the only trans protagonists in video games.

What’s beautiful about Celeste is that it caters to so many different players. If you want to challenge your skills, the game will give you that chance. But if you just want to experience the story and follow the character’s journey, there are accessibility tools to help you overcome the game’s difficulties with ease.

CONTROL ULTIMATE EDITION

Control is like a David Lynch film come to life. It follows a woman named Jesse on her journey into the Federal Bureau of Control. This mysterious, dilapidated building has all the stuffy appearances of a federal office. However, it’s filled with the unexplained — guns that transform, cursed objects, and more.

What makes Control so impressive is how Remedy uses its atmosphere to tell a story. The Federal Bureau of Control feels like a living being, and you’re constantly stuck in situations that require nuanced thinking to escape. With its bizarre aesthetic and mind-bending gameplay, Control is one of the most unique games on this list.

DEATH STRANDING DIRECTOR’S CUT

Death Stranding is perhaps the strangest game to come out in the past decade, and the Director’s Cut doesn’t change that. However, this edition of the game does smooth its edges a bit, and helps fine-tune the game into a more palatable — but equally glorious — creation.

In Death Stranding you play as a porter named Sam in an apocalyptic world. Your job, for the most part, is to deliver packages around the United States, reconnecting humanity after what amounts to nuclear fallout.

If it sounds odd, that’s because it is, but creator Hideo Kojima’s bizarre genius shines through with incredible progression systems and a story that will keep you guessing until the very end.

DOOM

2016’s Doom is built on speed, acrobatics, and an absolutely killer soundtrack. Doomguy moves fast and has a huge arsenal with which to devastate the demonic forces. Guns — both simple and absurd — grenades, fists, chainsaws, and the BFG itself will help you burn your way across Mars and through hell.

The game is bloody, metal as hell, and surprisingly funny. Doom makes you feel like a god, capable of clearing any hurdle the game can throw at you, and it doesn’t offer a single dull level in its lengthy campaign.

GOD OF WAR

God of War is not only the best game on this list, it’s one of the best games ever made. It elegantly mixes the existing God of War universe and characters with a new mythology to build a beautiful tale of childhood, fatherhood, and forgiveness. Its action and puzzle-solving are no slouches, either.

God of War is both intimate and sprawling, with each piece of ambient dialogue pairing perfectly with the vista in front of you. It’s an astounding achievement, and with its range of difficulty and accessibility settings, it’s a must-play for almost anyone.

GHOST OF TSUSHIMA

Ghost of Tsushima is a complex action game with an engaging story and a fun cast of characters. It also takes inspiration from 13th-century Japan and the films of Akira Kurosawa.

Exploring Ghost of Tsushima’s open world is fun enough, but the different styles it offers players is its most delightful feature. You can approach a base and fight honorably like a samurai, calling your foes out to battle you one at a time. Or you can take a stealthier path, defeating enemies before they even know you’re there.

This dichotomy plays into the game’s story and world, as the island’s culture changes from one of honor and tradition to that of desperation. And that’s what keeps Ghost of Tsushima memorable in a sea of open-world games.

HOLLOW KNIGHT VOID HEART EDITION

Hollow Knight is a Metroidvania set in a tiny kingdom of bugs. You control the titular character, blasting your way through tunnels and taking on increasingly powerful foes. As you go, you’ll collect new upgrades that help you open doors, solve puzzles, and traverse previously impassable landscapes.

Hollow Knight very openly mimics popular classics like Super Metroid. These kinds of throwbacks are popular and have been for some time, but Hollow Knight nails something many modern homages forget: a sense of mystery.

Finding your way through Hollow Knight is tough, and requires not only patience, but a mind for exploration and discovery.

MARVEL’S SPIDER-MAN AND MILES MORALES

Marvel’s Spider-Man and its standalone companion game, Marvel’s Spider-Man: Miles Morales, are both available on PlayStation’s Game Catalog. They’re also two of the best superhero games out there.

Both Spider-Man and Miles Morales nail the feel of their heroes — swinging through New York City, webbing enemies to the wall, etc. The controls are tuned tightly, so you’re able to deftly maneuver the environment and take on baddies with fluid, acrobatic attacks that feel like they belong in a movie trailer.

The MCU is as pervasive as properties come nowadays, but Marvel’s Spider-Man offers a breath of fresh air, taking place in a different universe with different versions of the characters we all know. Miles’ and Peter’s journeys are both excellent and unique, and shouldn’t be missed by Spidey fans or PlayStation Plus subscribers.

OUTER WILDS

Outer Wilds is a giant mystery, and the less that’s said about it, the better.

The gist is that your small solar system resets every 22 minutes. Your job is to discover why that’s happening, and put the clues together so you can attempt to stop it.

In Outer Wilds you’ll spend much of your time gathering information for the game’s central mystery. You won’t be killing creatures or gaining experience points. The only thing there is to gain is knowledge, which will propel you to bizarre and interesting places. And once you’re finally done, you’ll wish you could erase it all from your memory and play it again.

PREY

Prey is a tense crawl through a recently collapsed advanced society, built with the creativity of Arkane’s other titles. It starts with one of the best fake-outs in modern games, and continues to push into the bizarre and creepy throughout its run time. With deep progression and crafting systems, as well as fascinating characters, it’s the modern BioShock.

Part of what makes Prey stand out is the constant tension it places you under. Because the primary enemies can blend into the environment, every cup or random item could be a Mimic ready to attack you and take up your precious resources. (Imagine if every cheese wheel in Skyrim could suddenly end your life.) This all creates a feeling of constant paranoia, and it’s almost guaranteed that you’ll get a jump scare every time you start to feel safe.

RETURNAL

After years creating arcade-y games, Returnal is Housemarque’s first attempt at a “AAA” title. After crash-landing on a mysterious planet, you’ll control Selene, a spacefarer with a mysterious past. As you go on your adventure, you’ll discover that Selene is canonically returned to her ship each time she dies. By battling through various environments, you’ll discover new tools and uncover the game’s abundant interlocking mysteries.

Despite the resources poured into it, Returnal still holds on to Housemarque’s arcade roots. It’s a roguelite that mixes in bullet hell elements to create a cacophony of lights and sound. But as you improve and find better and better weapons and tools, you’ll learn to navigate between the bullets and dodge your way to victory.

It’s Housemarque’s best and most interesting game to date, and it feels great to play with the haptics in the PS5’s DualSense controller.

TETRIS EFFECT

Tetris Effect is a pretty straightforward recommendation. It’s the Tetris you know and love, albeit with ever-changing backgrounds, music, and visual designs. There’s an intense hypnotic quality to the stages, allowing you to focus on the colorful environments while your brain automatically places your Tetrominoes.

Tetris Effect beats out some other incredible games on this list not because of its gameplay — again, it’s just Tetris — but because of its vibes. A simple shift in the music or the visual language can drastically affect how you play, and when you marry that to one of the best and most classic puzzle games of all time, it’s an incredible win.